Captain Hook
Peter Banning / Peter Pan
Tinkerbell
Smee
Granny Wendy
Moira Banning
Jack 'Jackie' Banning
Maggie Banning
Liza
Inspector Good
Tootles
Pockets
Ace
Rufio
Thud Butt
Don't Ask
Too Small
Latchboy
No Nap
Lost Boy
Additional Lost Boy
Young Peter
5-Year-Old Peter Pan (as Maxwell Hoffman)
Peter's Mother
Mermaid
Mermaid (as Regina Russell)
Peter Pan in Play
Drama Teacher
Jane in Play
Pianist
Lost Boy in Play
Coach
Umpire
Little League Player (as Jacob Hoffman)
Brad (as Geoff Lower)
Dr. Fields
Ron
Jim
Secretary (as Brenda Isaacs)
Secretary
Chauffeur
Young Wendy
Shadow
Prostitute
Prostitute (as Randi Pareira)
Tickles
Noodler
Bill Jukes
Gutless
Pirate Jailer
Baby Peter Banning
Man in Stands
Toothless Cripple
Screaming Pirate (as Mike Runyard)
Growling Pirate
Lost Boy (uncredited)
Pirate (uncredited)
Shoe-Stealing Pirate (uncredited)
Pegleg (uncredited)
Baseball Game Attendee (uncredited)
Colonial Lost Boy (uncredited)
Parent (uncredited)
Woman Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)
Blacksmith (uncredited)
Man Kissing on Bridge (uncredited)
The Drunk Pirate (uncredited)
Doctor (uncredited)
Baby Tinkerbell (uncredited)
Praising Pirate (uncredited)